ED can always be successfully treated by a specialist
A recent study estimated that 30 million American men suffer15 from various degrees of ED (erectile dysfunction) ranging from mild to severe3. It is clearly an age-related phenomenon since the prevalence of ED increases significantly with age. However, it may occur at any age and Dr. Werner has treated a significant number of men in their teens, twenties and thirties.
By age 40, approximately 40% of men experience mild to moderate erectile dysfunction. Roughly 5% are never able to achieve an erection rigid enough for penetration4.
In the majority of cases involving men older than 35, the causes are primarily physical. In men younger than 35, the causes tend to be primarily psychological. However, even in these cases, medical intervention can always manage a man’s ED, and sometimes solve the problem too. Learn More about ED in men younger than 35.
Regardless of age, the best treatment plans for ED are based on a thorough evaluation of all the possible causes. There are also books and products that we can recommend for you regarding your ED.
Causes of Erectile Dysfunction
There are four main causes of erectile dysfunction:
Blood must be able to move into the penis and stay there to maintain an erection. Arteries are the vehicles that bring blood into the penis. Any process that damages the arteries would make a man more likely to have ED. A history of arterial disease (e.g. heart attacks, strokes or peripheral vascular disease) indicates that the penile arteries are also at risk. Anything that would make a man more likely to have a heart attack or stroke will make him more likely to have ED. This includes smoking, diabetes, hypertension, high cholesterol and sub-optimal exercise and diet. In fact, ED usually appears before any of these more severe manifestations of vessel disease. One of the main reasons for this is that the artery to the penis is smaller than the heart or limb arteries, and gets clogged first. The development of ED is often the first sign that a man is at significantly increased risk of a heart attack or stroke.
The neurological system must be in tact in order to achieve an erection. The most common cause of neurologic ED is diabetes, which usually affects both nerves and blood flow. Other causes include previous surgeries, spinal cord injury, strokes, multiple sclerosis or other systemic neurological diseases.
Significantly low testosterone and thyroid hormones, or a very high prolactin (another pituitary hormone) may cause problems with erections.
ED can often occur for psychological reasons, even when any related physical problems are minimal. However, many men have a significant psychological response (or secondary reaction) to what is, at least at first, primarily a physical problem. Once a man loses confidence in his erections, his anxiety levels may increase. This can make it even harder to achieve and maintain an erection. Thus, a vicious cycle is created. Our job is to break this cycle.
Evaluating and Diagnosing ED
Your first appointment should last between 45 and 60 minutes. It will include:
A member of our team will take a thorough medical history in order to place your erectile dysfunction within a medical context. He will also take a full sexual history. This may include questions such as:
- How long have you had the erectile dysfunction?
- What happens when you try to have intercourse?
- Do you have decreased rigidity?
- Do you have difficulty maintaining your erection?
- At what point do you lose your erection?
- Do you wake up at any point with an erection?
- How rigid are the nocturnal erections?
- What is your sexual interest level (libido) like?
- Does your penis have a curve, bend, or twist in it when it is rigid?
- Is your ejaculation normal?
- Is ejaculation early (premature) or delayed?
- What is the status of your relationship?
- How is the relationship going?
- How is your ED affecting the relationship?
A member of our team will explain to you, in terms that you will understand, how erections work and why yours may not be working.
Your practitioner will perform a focused physical examination on your penis and testes. (This evaluation does not substitute for a general physical examination).
A member of our team will perform a simple, completely painless test that measures how sensitive your penis is to vibration (biothesiometry) as well as perform specialized testing to assess the function of your penis. This may include:
- A Rigi-scan to measure the quantity and quality of your nighttime erections. (This involves a simple machine that you take home with you.) Watch our video: How to use and troubleshoot the RigiScan
- An ultrasound to measure the blood flow through the penis.
Blood tests are also done to measure hormone, cholesterol, and glucose status.
Once we have completed your evaluation, we will discuss ED treatment options with you. We will consider these options in light of your medical history, the physical and specialized testing that has been performed and, of course, what preferences you have stated.
Oral Treatment Options
There are four oral medications for the treatment of ED: Viagra (sildenafil), Levitra (vardenafil), Cialis (tadalafil), and Stendra (avanafil). They are all members of the class known as phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitors.
How do they work?
All four of these medications have the same mechanism of action. When a man is sexually aroused, a messenger chemical (nitric oxide) is released. This causes a cascade of biochemical reactions: the blood vessels and tissues of the penis relax and dilate, allowing blood to rush in and an erection to occur. But there is another enzyme in the body, called PDE5, which reverses what this messenger chemical (nitric oxide) does. All four oral medications work by blocking the enzyme PDE5.
It is important to note that these medications don’t make you aroused. They just give you a better erection when you are aroused by blocking this enzyme. This is nice for your partner to know that it s/he that is giving you the excitement that gets you the erection, not the pill.
They are so expensive that they get in the way of my wanting to use them. Can I get them cheaper?
Viagra (sildenafil) and Cialis (tadalafil) are now off of patent, and available in generic form, which are already cheaper than the branded, but should continue to come down in price.
All four compounds are available from compounding pharmacies. The medication is the same, but for those medications still under patent the mode of delivery and/or the dosage needs to be changed, in order for compounding pharmacy to make them legally. Thus for example, avanafil is available as a 200mg troche (which goes under the tongue), vardenafil is available as a 20mg troche, and tadalafil is available as a 27mg capsule (rather than tablet.)
You should be able to purchase a full maximum dosage of these medications, directly from a regular or compounding pharmacy (with a doctor’s prescription) for $4.00-$7.00. Experts are hopeful that the prices will continue to come down even further.
Who cannot take them?
Please note that all of these drugs are contraindicated for a man who is:
- Currently using nitrates or has retinitis pigmentosis (which is an eye disease)
These oral medications also should be not be taken by men with a predisposition to potentially hazardous cardiovascular events. These conditions include:
- Unstable angina
- Congestive heart failure
- Taking multiple antihypertensive drugs
- MI, heart attack, CVA (stroke), or life threatening arrhythmia within the last six months.
- Hypotension, decreased blood pressure (BP <90/50) or hypertension, increased blood pressure (BP>170/110)
- Patients on alpha blocks for high blood pressure or prostate problems should not take Levitra or Cialis
The general rule of thumb is that if your health makes sexual activity dangerous, you should not take these medications.
How do I maximize their use?
It is important to understand how these medications are absorbed and broken down (pharmacokinetics) in order to get the best results from them. The chart below helps summarize this information.
- The maximum dosage of Viagra is 100mg. It is often the strongest medication available and often produces the best result. However, it must be taken on an empty stomach if all of it is to get absorbed. As a result, it often has the most side effects.
- It peaks in the blood stream in about 1 hour. Half is gone at 4 hours and most is out of the system after 8 hours. Thus, it is important to have sexual activity when the medicine is close to its peak levels.
- Side effects include: Headache, flushing, nasal congestion, temporary abnormal vision, heartburn and blood shot eyes.
- The maximum FDA approved dosage is 20mg. Tadalafil is the longest acting medication, which is the main reason why it is the most popular.
- It peaks in the blood stream about 2-4 hours after it is taken. Half is gone by 18 hours and the rest by 36 hours. Thus, it is often called “the weekend drug.” However, it is important to remember that there is less and less in the blood stream after 4 hours. So, for example, it is almost never as powerful at 24 hours as it is at 12 hours.
- Tadalafil remains in the bloodstream for a long time, so if a lower dosage is taken daily, there will always be some in the system. Thus, for men who have only modest ED, a daily 2.5mg – 5mg tadalafil may be enough for them always to be able to achieve and maintain a good erection. The daily tadalafil is also approved for lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) which are often from an enlarged prostate. Thus, sometimes (with a lot of effort) your specialist can get it paid for by insurance companies for men who have both ED and urination symptoms.
- Side effects include: Headache, flushing, nasal congestion, heartburn, blood shot eyes, and back or leg cramps. Also note that whatever side affects you do experience may last longer, because it stays in your system longer.
- The maximum dose is 20mg. It peaks in the blood stream at about 1 hour. Half is gone by 4 hours and almost all of it is gone by 8 hours.
- It is available under the brand name of Staxyn, which is placed under the tongue (sublingually).
- Side effects include: Headache, flushing, nasal congestion, upset stomach or back pain.
- The maximum dose is 200mg. It is the most rapidly effective oral ED drug. (PDE 5 inhibitor)
- It may give effective results after 15 minutes. Half is gone at 4 hours and the rest by 8 hours.
- Side effects include: Headache, flushing, nasal congestion, upset stomach or back pain.
We often prescribe more than one PDE 5 inhibitor for our patients, as they may find themselves in different sexual situations. Sometimes they need the medication to be the absolute strongest it can be. Sometimes the flexibility of a longer acting drug is needed. Sometimes, you just need it quickly!
Oral medications work for 70% of men. For many of these men, it is truly a wonder drug, giving them excellent, predictable, and long-lasting erections. Oral medications have revolutionized the treatment of ED by bringing the issue into the open and giving many men hope.
However, for 30% of patients, the oral medications fail. Some men simply cannot take them for medical reasons. For other men, the oral medications do not work well or do not work at all. For others the side effects are so severe (terrible headaches or reflux for example) that it is not worth it, even if they get a good erection. These men are often more unhappy than before they sought treatment since they are convinced that there is no help for them.
The good news is that there are plenty of other treatment options to explore; we can get any man an erection if the pills, taken at maximum dosage, and correctly, are not working!
What if you can’t take one of the available oral medications or if the medications aren’t working the way you’d like? One of the options available for the treatment of ED is the self-injection of medication into the penis. This often sounds scary to the patient but most men will tell you that the injection doesn’t hurt at all. Some describe it as completely painless. Others report that if feels as if they have been flicked with a rubber band. The injection is extremely quick and uses a very fine needle (usually a 29 or 30 gauge). And since the side of the penis doesn’t have many pain receptors, there is little sensation.
It works like this. The medication goes into the penis with a device that’s similar to the ones used by diabetics. A disposable syringe, with a very fine needle, is placed on the injector. The device is placed against the side of the penis, and you press a button. A spring pushes a very thin needle into the penis and, at the same time, pushes the medication into the penis. Watch our video: How to use the Autoinjector for Penile Injections
The three most common medications used for injections are prostaglandin E1, papaverine, and phentolamine. All three act by relaxing the smooth muscles and causing the arteries to dilate, making it possible for blood to get into and be kept in the penis. Prostaglandin E1 received FDA approval in 1996 for ED treatment. It is currently marketed and available in prescription plans under two brand names, Caverject Impulse and Edex. However, all three are available in different combinations and strengths.
Each medication has different characteristics:
- Prostaglandin E1 or Alprostadil
- Prostaglandin E1 is a powder that is mixed with a fluid prior to use. This is due to the fact that it is stable as a powder at room temperature, but not as a liquid. Prostaglandin E1 can cause some temporary short-lived aching in the penis. Although it is not medically concerning, it can be uncomfortable. Discomfort is experienced by approximately 20% of patients and is most common in patients who have neurological erectile dysfunction (resulting from, for example, diabetes or post-radical prostatectomy).
- Papaverine and Phentolamine
- Papaverine is a smooth muscle relaxant. It acts directly on the blood vessel walls to relax and thus dilate, as well as activate, the trapping mechanism. It is usually mixed with phentolamine which is an alpha-blocker which causes smooth muscle relaxation through a different mechanism.
- The papaverine and phentolamine come in a liquid, do not need to be refrigerated, and do not cause aching.
Usually, one of three formulations is used:
- Prostalandin E1 (stable as a powder, but needs to be refrigerated as a liquid.)
- Bimix: is a combination of Papaverine and Phentolamine. It comes as a liquid only, but does not need to be refrigerated. This makes it very convenient for men who travel, or those who don’t want to store their medication in a shared refrigerator. It also never causes any aching.
- Trimix: is a combination of Papaverine, Phentolamine, and ProstaglandinE1. Because it contains PGE1 it needs to be refrigerated and can cause aching in some patients. However, it is often stronger than an equivalent dosage of Bimix (papaverine and phentolamine alone), and thus is often used.
How do I learn to do the injections?
Learning how to use the injections, though intimidating, is actually quite straight-forward. It is important that your practitioner schedules you for several visits, both to teach you how to do the injections comfortably, and to figure out the right dosage.
At Maze, this usually takes three visits. At the first visit you receive your first injection, to introduce you to them, and to see how you respond. Based on your experience, you can decide whether or not you would like to continue with them.
At your second visit, you will receive a second injection (the dosage of which is based on your response to your first injection). You will also be supplied with the auto injector, and taught how to use it. You will be strongly encouraged to practice it (empty-no syringe) at home.
On your third visit, you will give yourself an injection, under our observation. By then, we will have figured out the right dosage and medication, based on your responses to the previous two injections. You are then usually sent home with five preloaded syringes, sometimes of increasing dosages to use at home.
Some men need more practice and coaching than other. Rest assured that we will work with you for as long as it takes to get you comfortable with the technique.
How good will my erection be?
Our goal is for you to achieve a great erection that can last as long as you want (up to two hours). If you have a problem with your trapping mechanism, this may not be possible, but it is what most of our patients achieve. We are successful in getting about 90% of our patients, many of whom have failed with pills and injections at other centers, great erections.
If I have already failed injections somewhere else, can you help me?
It is extraordinarily frustrating for us how poorly penile self-injections are managed by “shot clinics” and non-specialists. We estimate that 80% of men who have failed injections at other practices, are successful at ours. This is because we have the expertise and take the time to insure that each patient has the right equipment, training and dosages he needs to succeed.
What are the possible complications of penile self-injections?
There are two potential complications, but they are rare if patients are taught how to inject properly and follow the dosages prescribed.
The first is a prolonged erection, or “priapism.” When you have a rigid erection, you are trapping the blood in your penis. This causes pressure, which makes your penis hard but also acts like a tourniquet around your penile arteries, shutting off the flow. This prevents fresh blood from coming into the penis. When your erection goes down, the arteries then can bring fresh blood into your penis. If the erection remains rigid for too long, you are not getting fresh blood into your penis. This is why we ask patients to call us if their erections last more than four hours. If left untreated for too long, a priapism can cause permanent damage. However, this is extremely rare, especially if the dosage is right and you don’t abuse it. If it happens, a priapism can almost always be taken care of in the office.
The second potential complication is developing scar tissue of the lining of the penis. This is also uncommon, particularly if you are taught the right technique. It is important that you vary the site in the penis and that you compress the site for five minutes after the injection. This prevents bleeding on the inside which can cause scar tissue. This is, of course, part of what we teach you.
How long have penile injections been around?
Penile injections were developed in 1983 and were the second method developed for the treatment of erectile dysfunction. They thus predated the pills by more than a decade. Viagra was the first pill and was approved March 29, 1998.
How do I maintain spontaneity while using the injections?
In some ways, the injection is a more spontaneous solution for treating ED than oral medications since it can be used right before a sexual encounter.
Also, in our experience people vastly prefer excellent sex to spontaneous sex. There are very few periods in a person’s life where sex can be regularly spontaneous. Working around parents and siblings, roommates, and then children means that people generally put far more planning into having sex than they think.
Will my body get used to the injections to the point where they stop working?
There are certain drugs to which the body routinely builds up a tolerance, requiring more and more to achieve the same effects. This is called “tachyphylaxis.” Fortunately, this does not happen with these injections. In fact we often see that when men start using the injections, their own erections (when not using an injection) improve. This is probably a combination of physical changes to the penis ( which is both stretched and getting more oxygen) and more confidence. However, some men need somewhat higher doses as they age, just due to the natural aging process. The vast majority of men are able to use the injections for the duration of their whole sexual life.
Shock Wave Therapy/Pressure Wave Therapy
LI-ESWT (Low Intensity- Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy) is a relatively new, painless method for treatment of ED. It has been proven, in the past 10 years, to be extremely effective, in improving ED in most men.
The extraordinary feature of LI-ESWT is that it is the first potential non-surgical curative treatment for ED. Current treatment of ED, using pills or injections, is extremely successful, but they have always relied on ongoing management of the condition. That is, anyone using pills or other treatments must plan to use them before each sexual activity. LI-ESWT treatment potentially improves a man’s sexual functioning whenever he is sexually active. This may allow him to get and maintain a good erection without requiring an immediate intervention, or improve his function so that he can use a less powerful method to be successful (i.e. function with using pills as opposed to injections.)
Vacuum Erection Device (VED)
The VED is a viable alternative to oral medications or injection therapy. The VED is a cylinder that goes over the whole penis. A vacuum is then created in it, by pumping out the air. This pulls blood into the penis giving you an erection. A band is then placed around the base of the penis to hold the blood in.
There are many different brands of VED. Some of them have a battery operated pump and some are manually pumped. It is important that you get a medical one, which has a built in pop-off valve, so that you do not injure the penis by applying too much pressure. It is also important that you not leave the band around the base of the penis for too long, so that fresh blood can get into the penis.
Advantages of the VED
If the VED works for you, it is a one time purchase, usually covered by your insurance. It does not take very long to apply. You don’t have to worry about side effects since there is no medication taken.
Disadvantages of the VED
Many men do not like the way the VED feels. Some find the band uncomfortable. For some men, it is hard for the scrotal contents not to be sucked into the cylinder, causing discomfort. (Some VED’s come with a piece to try to prevent this.) Also, even if the penis beyond the band is rigid, the part of the penis under the skin and attached to your pubic bone is not. Thus, you may get some hinging (bending) of the penis.
Most importantly, many men do not really get a truly rigid erection from the VED.
MUSE is alprostadil (the same chemical your body already makes on its own to get an erection) put into a pellet form. The pellet is placed by the manufacturer into a disposable applicator. Prior to initiating sex, the man urinates and then places the applicator about one inch into the tip of the penis (the urethra.) The pellet is then pushed out of the applicator and into the urethra. The man then compresses the penis so the pellet of alprostadil cannot come out.
Advantages of MUSE
Some men like this method because it acts quickly. It is paid for by some insurance companies.
Disadvantages of MUSE
Many men do not get a very good erection from MUSE. Most men do not like putting something into the tip of their penis. Many men get burning from the medication in the urethra. Since the medicine is not delivered directly into the erection chambers, much of it leaks out into the general circulation. This causes some men’s blood pressure to drop. (Fortunately, this is quite rare.) In our practice, though we offer it to every patient, few patients have tried it, and even fewer stick with it.
Penile Prosthesis (Penile Implant)
The earliest treatment for ED, and one still frequently used, is placement of a penile implant. The technique involves placing cylinders in the two erection chambers of the penis. When they are inflated or bent upwards, they allow a man to have a rigid penis. Originally, they consisted of bendable rods put into the erection chambers. However, they have developed significantly since that time.
Today most prosthesis are inflatable. They consist of a closed system filled with saline. There is a reservoir that holds most of the fluid when you don’t want to be erect. It is hidden under your abdominal muscles or, occasionally, in your scrotum. There is a pump placed in your scrotum which you can feel and manipulate through the scrotal skin painlessly. When you want an erection, you literally pump the fluid from the hidden reservoir to the cylinders in the erection chambers, giving yourself an erection. Your orgasm and sensation will be the same. When you no longer need/desire the erection, you press a valve on the pump and then gently squeeze the penis. This transfers the fluid out of the penile cylinders and back into the reservoir.
The surgery, when done by an expert with a lot of experience, is quite short. It is done in the hospital. Most physicians keep their patients in the hospital overnight, though some discharge them home the day of the surgery. All of the pieces can be placed through one small incision, which is either in the scrotum, or right above the pubic bone, in the middle. None of the pieces are visible.
Herbal Alternatives for Treating ED
For many years, Yohimbe, which is found in Rubaceae and related trees, was considered an impotence remedy. The efficacy of Yohimbe has been debated for a number of years. Many studies have concluded that it is no better than a placebo. Others have concluded that it does improve erections, though modestly. It is still occasionally used for men with very mild erectile dysfunction, especially when a lack of desire and psychological factors are major issues.
A multitude of multivitamins or herbal supplements are marketed for erectile dysfunction. At the moment, there are no reliable studies that prove the efficacy of any of these medications. The supplement combinations are not regulated by the FDA, and there are those that may be not only ineffective, but also harmful. Some include hormones, which remain controversial (because they are possibly dangerous) when used by patients with normal hormone levels.
Herbal supplements must be viewed with caution and skepticism until there is evidence that they are safe and effective, and that the medications actually contain what the bottle says they do.
For more information about Erectile Dysfunction and male impotence, please complete the form below.
"Let's Talk About It": A short documentary about Erectile Dysfunction.
Treatment options for Erectile Dysfunction.
Treating Erectile Dysfunction.
In A Patient's Own Words
I came to Dr. Werner after having a prostate issue that caused Erectile Dysfunction. I had it for at least four years, and was given Viagra, which just wasn’t doing it for me. I wanted my mojo back! I found Dr. Werner on the internet, and came in to see him. That was the best decision I ever made.
My first appointment was surprising; it was really great. It was such a pleasant experience, and seeing Dr. Werner continued to be pleasant. It’s better than any other practice. Now, sex is very enjoyable again — my anxiety is gone, and my youth and vigor are back. Dr. Werner resolved my issues quickly, and I didn’t have to keep trying to explain what was going on with me, because he had already figured it out.
It’s ok to take care of yourself. You become a better human when you take care of your own issues.
– W –
Last updated: November 2021